As a dog owner, finding the best food can be difficult when constrained by your budget and accessibility. Both Purina Pro Plan and Acana are well-liked products among pet owners, but which one is better?
Acana is the better product, especially compared to Purina Pro Plan. Choose Acana if you want premium ingredients and a superior nutritional profile. Acana has a high price tag, though. If you’re on a budget, Purina Pro Plan is also a good and healthy option.
We’ll walk you through a broad comparison of Purina Pro Plan and Acana in this article. We’ll then go into the benefits and drawbacks to help you select the one that best meets your needs.
Before reading this guide, “Purina Pro Plan or Acana,” check out: Worst Dog Food Brands To Avoid (+5 We Recommend)! (2023) and 7 Common Goldendoodle Food Allergies (2023).
It’s essential to do a basic comparison between both brands before diving into the specific details of each one. That way, you’ll have a better understanding of how they compare in terms of nutritional content, cost, and safety. When selecting your dog’s feeding plan, you should take these aspects into account.
Fortunately, both the federal and state governments have strict regulations on pet food production and distribution. As a result, by reading the labels, you can be sure to gain an overview of the item’s nutritional content. This is the most crucial factor on which the majority of pet owners base their preferences.
To begin this comparison, we’ll provide some basic information about the nutritional benefits of Purina Pro Plan and Acana.
Without a doubt, protein serves as the most significant macronutrient in a pet’s diet. Pets require a consistent, protein-rich diet in order to thrive. It’s crucial to make sure that the protein offered by the food brand you select is not only highly concentrated but also of great quality.
Acana largely outperforms Purina Pro Plan in terms of protein percentage. This may not necessarily be the case, though, based on the precise product you end up purchasing.
For instance, while around 4% more protein per serving in Acana’s dry dog food is more than in Purina Pro Plan’s wet version, the former has about 1% less fat per serving.
In summary, based just on protein levels, the scale might tip either way. The variations are negligibly minor compared to the total health of your pet. Acana is your best option, though, if your dog has very high protein requirements and even a small variation might influence your choice.
As one of the primary sources of energy, fats are another crucial macronutrient. Most pets rely on lipids to meet their energy requirements, unlike humans, who predominantly consume carbs.
Making sure your dog gets plenty of macronutrients should be your first priority — they provide a range of health advantages.
Acana once again has a tiny advantage in terms of fats. Up to 2% more fats are included in certain products compared to rival companies. Therefore, Acana could be preferable in this situation, particularly for people who want to increase their pet’s consumption of fat.
The majority of adult dogs and cats in good health don’t need to eat any complex carbs. They do, however, require fiber to keep their digestive systems in good shape. With noticeably more crude fiber than its rival, Acana excels once more in this third macronutrient.
In conclusion, Acana is a better option from a nutritional standpoint.
Safety and Quality
Indicators of a high-quality dog food product go beyond just protein, fat, and fiber. We believe micronutrient quality is far more significant than macronutrient quantity. As a result, we’ll be examining the quality of the ingredients in each of these products, as well as any potential health issues.
Acana ingredients are frequently superior. The company takes pride in using only natural, organic, animal, and plant materials. They enrich their meals with a variety of vitamins, minerals, and probiotics and only use natural preservatives. Acana has also set up an Ingredient Transparency page on its website.
But let’s say you’re on a tight budget. The FDA has also suggested Purina Pro Plan is among the most nutritionally dense alternatives available. It could still be a great substitute.
Although there are benefits to organic and sustainably sourced meats and grains, as long as the fundamental nutritional needs are satisfied, we can tell you that they won’t be missing out on anything.
However, if your dog suffers from medical disorders or dietary intolerances that might be aggravated by specific ingredients, spending a little more to get access to the finest ingredients may be worthwhile.
For instance, preservatives, artificial coloring, and soybean oil that are frequently included in Purina Pro Plan products might have an impact on a pet’s health. Furthermore, they contain preserved animal fat, which, if ingested in excess, may cause a variety of ailments.
However, if your dog is typically healthy and you’re feeding according to the manufacturer’s instructions, there’s a good chance they’ll do just fine with the less expensive choice.
It’s also crucial to remember that Purina Pro Plan has had a number of recalls. The most recent took place in 2021 regarding cans of wet cat food that may have contained residues of plastic.
Here is a brief history of the recalls that Purina Pro Plan has had in recent years
- Pro Plan Complete Essentials by Purina In July 2021, Tuna Entrée in Sauce Wet Cat Food was recalled owing to the potential for plastic pieces within some of its 3 oz. cans.
- In late March 2019, the company issued a limited recall for one of their Muse cat food varieties.
- In March 2016 a recall was issued for Pro Plan wet dog food that was sold in tubs owing to insufficient vitamin and mineral content.
- A batch of Purina ONE dog food was also voluntarily recalled by Purina in the summer of 2013 because it could have been contaminated with salmonella.
Even if these problems are to be expected given the company’s almost century-long history, they should still be taken into account if you only want to give your pet the finest.
Acana has never had a product recall, which is a remarkable accomplishment for a business in the pet food sector.
In summary, Acana is unquestionably the better, safer option if your budget permits. Purina Pro Plan is still a great choice if your pet is healthy and you’re searching for an affordable option.
Purina Pro Plan is unquestionably the more affordable option between the two, as we’ve highlighted many times throughout this article. The difference in price might vary based on the specific product you’re looking at, but for some items, the Purina Pro Plan price per calorie may be as low as half of its Acana equivalent.
Given that it can be challenging to determine differences in volume, weight, and moisture content in some cases, we’d argue that price per calorie could be the best criterion, in this case, to distinguish between the two brands.
With so many factors at play, it can be difficult to determine just how much more affordable Purina Pro Plan products are overall. However, it’s reasonable to conclude that they remain the most reasonably priced choice.
The pet food you can afford is generally the best choice for you and your pet. As long as you take care to select the option with the highest nutritional content that is also within your budget, you’re doing a great job as a dog owner.
Even if purchasing organic, ethically sourced goods has a number of clear benefits, there are times when you just want a full, appetizing alternative that won’t break the budget.
We could spend the whole day comparing features and nutritional information, but the true measure of any product is how it is being received by its users.
As a result, we combed through a number of pet-related discussion boards, looking for reviews that would provide you with some perspective into the brand that might be more suitable for you.
For instance, some pet owners assert that pups’ young, developing bodies may find Acana’s highly nutritious foods a little too rich. Since they want to support their dogs’ quick development and general health, they choose to give them Purina Pro Plan products up to the age of roughly a year.
After that, they may transition to richer options like Acana.
Even though protein is an essential element that should be included in every dog’s diet, too much of it can make puppies gain weight quickly and develop their joints abnormally. Because of this, the high protein content of Acana turns out to be a disadvantage in this situation.
Additionally, an owner claims their dogs have experienced digestive problems after consuming foods from both brands, indicating that their fiber level may be a little low.
However, the majority of pet owners believe that Acana offers the best quality. Since many people start their puppies on Purina Pro Plan, they eventually convert to Acana as soon as their pet is old enough.
Additionally, Acana is the ideal option for dogs that are sensitive to certain grains or preservatives.
Both Purina Pro Plan and Acana are top-notch pet food suppliers with a lengthy history of satisfied clients. Acana, though, comes out on top in terms of quality. Their goods have an outstanding nutritional profile and are created entirely of organic components.
On the other hand, Purina Pro Plan is still a fantastic, cost-effective choice for owners whose pets are in generally good condition.
Frequently Asked Questions
Veterinarians around the world recommend Purina Pro Plan for dogs and cats.
Purina Pro Plan offers grain-free wet dog food, but no dry options.
Purina Pro Plan is generally of higher quality and more expensive than Purina One with more formulas available. Pro Plan typically has more key nutrients and probiotics compared to Purina One.
Conclusion for “Purina Pro Plan or Acana”
We know how worried dog owners get for their fur babies when deciding what the best food to give them would be. Often, you might find yourself stuck trying to decide between two brands, such as Purina Pro Plan and Acana.
This is why we created this comparison to help you decide what’s best for your pet. We hope you enjoyed reading this detailed guide.
If you find this guide, “Purina Pro Plan or Acana,” helpful, check out:
- Best Food for a Goldendoodle Puppy (2023) – Top 10!
- The 8 Best Dog Foods for Older Small Dogs with Few Teeth! (2023)
- Best Dog Food for a Bernedoodle – Top 8 Picks! (2023)
Learn more by watching “The MOST Important Foods to Feed Your Dog!!” down below:
Garrett loves animals and is a huge advocate for all Doodle dog breeds. He owns his own Goldendoodle named Kona. In addition, he volunteers at the Humane Society of Silicon Valley, where he fosters dogs and helps animals. Garrett enjoys writing about Doodles and believes that dogs can teach humans more about how to live than humans can teach a dog.
Why Trust We Love Doodles?
At We Love Doodles, we’re a team of writers, veterinarians, and puppy trainers that love dogs. Our team of qualified experts researches and provides reliable information on a wide range of dog topics. Our reviews are based on customer feedback, hands-on testing, and in-depth analysis. We are fully transparent and honest to our community of dog owners and future owners.