Positive dog training starts in puppyhood and will continue throughout your dog’s life. The time you invest in training your puppy will pay off down the road with a happy and well-trained puppy. If you have a stubborn dog, it may take longer to train him properly, and you’ll need to have the right equipment and plenty of patience.
Dogs that display disturbing and dangerous behavior should work with reward-based training that is pain-free and force-free. As a pet parent, you should learn about dog training and behavior fundamentals to ensure the best chance of success. All dog training needs to avoid the use of intimidation, physical punishment, and fear. To be a good pet parent, you’ll need first to understand your dog’s perspective and all the misconceptions about the dominance theory.
The pet industry offers a vast array of collars and other dog training equipment that may be beneficial when positively training a stubborn dog. Suppose you’re looking for the best dog training equipment for a stubborn dog. In that case, our Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs Review will show you the perfect solution with some dog training collars allowing for multi-pet simultaneous cheerful dog training.
Dog training collars are also known as e-collars and feature a few settings. Before you use these collars on your furry best friend, you should strap one to your arm and test it to ensure that it’s safe to use on your dogs. The most crucial step when setting up an e-collar is to use them in the lowest setting or on the vibration mode so that you don’t hurt your dog.
The e-collar can be dangerous if not used correctly and under a positive dog trainer’s guidance. Finding a high-quality dog training collar for stubborn dogs is not easy, mainly because there are so many on the market.
Training your furry best friend is a lifelong way of life and should be done via positive dog training with rewards. If you’re having a hard time training your pup, always consult with a positive dog trainer. You can even do so via Skype or Zoom. In the meantime, here are our top 5 dog training collars with our detailed buying guide for 2021.
In a rush? Here are our top picks!
Pet Resolve now has a wonderful new upgrade with the removable shock function. You can remove the shock function and switch it to vibration and beep mode only. This premium dog training collar works well when training up to three dogs simultaneously. We like this dog training collar for stubborn dogs because it has a super long range with memory and does not use cheap plastic that breaks easily. Dogs can also swim across rivers with the collar on, and it will still work. With no lag in correction due to no standby mode, the Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar allows you to correct your dog instantly. This means no confusion, and your dog will understand the correction.
The Pet Resolve dog training system is made with durable materials that do not break if you drop it. Featuring a super long range of ¾ mile range (1312 yards), this works well for hunting and working dogs because it covers the vastest fields. This top-of-the-line training collar features plenty of positive ratings from satisfied consumers. Here’s the take with reviews:
“This product has probably saved my dog’s life. My dog is great but is lacking in common sense. When we first rescued him from the pound, he would bolt and runoff. He would run in front of cars without thinking and get close to being hit a few times. We purchased this product, and it has taught him that he can be out with us but needs to stay with us. Fast forward to yesterday, I left the remote on the driveway, and my wife accidentally ran it over with our two-ton van leaving the remote unusable. I contacted pet resolve, and they gave me a coupon for a replacement. Fantastic customer service.”
- Features Dog ID
- Designed with a ¾ mile range
- Waterproof collar (can be fully submerged)
- Ten levels of shock & vibration plus beeping function ( 3-modes)
- Removable shock mode.
Pet Safe is a well-known pet brand that’s been around for 30 years. This collar learns to recognize your dog’s bark, so it prevents the collar from giving your furry best friend a false correction. This collar is another waterproof collar crafted from durable nylon and plastic. It features a rechargeable battery with a 40-hour lifespan and gives your dog a safe reminder to be quiet.
What’s great about this collar is that it’s designed to differentiate your dog’s bark and other noises. This product features a test tool allowing you to test the product before training. There are 15 levels of adjustable static correction to help you with training.
- Adjustable for all dog breeds and sizes (adjusts up to 27 inches)
- Priced affordably
- Gentle & flexible with numerous control options
- Features unique bark sensing technology
- Useful for controlling excessive barking
- Crafted as a lightweight, waterproof collar
- Dogs receive the lowest level of correction from the collar when he begins barking.
- Features a built-in automatic stop feature for optimal safety
The Sport Dog Brand is one of the most recognized pet brands when it comes down to e- tracking and training categories. It features the Silent Partner technology that quickly determines your dog’s unique barking style and filters out all the rest to avoid any false corrections. This collar has three selectable modes. These include Temperament Learning, Progressive Correction, and User-Selected) There are also ten levels of static stimulation that you can choose from. This collar is waterproof and can be submerged up to 10 feet. The batteries are lithium-ion rechargeable and take 2 hours to charge, featuring a battery life of 200 hours per charge.
Temperament learning starts at level 1, increasing each time your dog barks within 30 seconds of the previous bark. We like this dog training e-collar for stubborn dogs because it offers a detailed operating guide, is priced well, uses the Silent Partner Technology, and learns your dog’s unique barking style.
- Waterproof & submersible
- Odor-resistant, sturdy, and coated nylon strap
- Priced affordably
- Features progressive correction
- Manual user selection from 1-10
- Senses what works best and stays there
This is a black stainless steel prong collar made in Germany. This model features a swivel for leash attachment. The links are removable and have slightly beveled prong tips. The links are crafted by interlocking each other and added or removed (up to 4 links) to make the collar shorter or longer.
The Herm Springer black stainless steel collar is crafted from black German sturdy steel that is good in all weather and will not rust. There is a martingale chain that slides for perfect correction. This collar works as an alternative to the choke chain and adds even pressure around the neck. Keep in mind that this dog training e-collar does not apply direct pressure to the trachea and that there is a center plate connector to allow for the middle link to be configured symmetrically. This enables the prongs to tighten in the same direction.
- Anti-rust black German steel for all-weather use
- Crafted with a swivel leash attachment
- Removable links
The PAT PET 2 dog training collar features a remote dog training system with a wireless receiver and remote. When using this dog training collar for stubborn dogs, you’ll find that you can send signals with the tone, vibration, or a stimulating sensation. The stimulation can be adjusted to a level that’s safe and comfortable for your dog. The PAT PET 2 is crafted with three training modes and has 16 adjustable shock levels. This is another waterproof e-training collar and has a receiver IPX7 waterproof and remote IPX5 that’s rainproof.
- 3000-foot range (1000 yards)
- Features blind operation buttons
- It can be used on all dog breeds from 5 pounds to 100 pounds.
- The device supports a maximum of two dogs training with only one remote transmitter.
- Crafted with auto-off protection
- Dog collar deactivates when vibration or static shock continues for longer than 10 seconds.
Keeping Dog Training Sessions Short & Successful
Optimum training sessions need to be three to five minutes in length a few times a day, working on only two to three behaviors each time. If the action that’s being taught is difficult or complicated, even shorter sessions may be needed.
Your job when training your pup is not to get stuck on one behavior when building long actions. Once your dog is successful with each step, you can raise the criterion and move up to the next level.
Fix Bad Behaviors by Reinforcing Plenty of Good Behaviors
Focus on all the good stuff your pup does and reinforce it instead of supporting the wrong behaviors. Timing is everything when training dogs, and improper timing using punishment methods leads to abuse.
If your dog does something right, reinforce with a treat or clock within half a second. On the other hand, if your pup does something less desirable, you should wait for 5 to 10 seconds after he does this behavior and redirect his behavior to better behavior, and then, of course, reinforce.
Positive Dog Training
We adore our dogs and want the best for them. Using positive dog training methods increases their love of learning and leaves out the fear factor. Patience is essential in dog training, and all dog training should avoid the punishment factor.
By teaching your dog’s mind and rewarding, you’ll get a whole lot more than trying to manipulate your dog’s body by force. Inexperienced dogs and pet parents should work together with a positive dog trainer so that you’ll get the more advanced behaviors at a much earlier age through positive dog training. Before starting with positive dog training, you should know the following:
- Understand what behaviors you want from your dog
- Redirect your pup, or prevent destructive behaviors from occurring before they start
- Understand that positive dog training is far better than negative dog training because it’s more effective and has no harmful side effects. It creates a balanced and happier relationship between you and your dog.
- Never punish for growling or anxiety; instead, opt for desensitization or systematic desensitization, a form of counter conditioning. Work together with a positive dog trainer to get the best results.
What to Do If Your Dog Makes a Mistake?
Never get mad! If your dog makes a mistake, you’ll need to stop and look at the situation through your dog’s eyes. You could be giving him or her incorrect cues or perhaps pushing your dog beyond his limits.
Sometimes things don’t work out during training in all situations, and find a positive solution without punishing your dog. Also, be sure that your cues are always consistent and that you’re not confusing your dog.
What are Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs?
E-collars emit stimulation or shock to ward off unwanted behavior. e-Collars have different levels of motivation that are adjustable and can help your dog with unwanted behaviors. An e-collar can be useful for small and large dogs, and with the adjustable level of stimulation, your dog can learn the required action.
Shock collars should never be used as a substitute for positive dog training, especially in young dogs. You’ll need to fully understand that if you just have relaxed walks with a high-energy dog breed, it’s not enough! Keep in mind that dogs need plenty of environmental stimulation, positive dog training starting from puppyhood, and plenty of off-leash exercises.
It’s essential to start with the lowest level of stimulation because each dog is different. e-Collars are beneficial in that they can keep your dog safe in dangerous environments or near busy streets. They can also help you with unwanted behaviors like excessive barking, digging, and, most significantly, jumping up on your guests.
How Does an E-Collar Work?
E-collars work by way of remote and the receiver on your dog’s collar. Navigating the many shock collars for dogs may be time-consuming and even challenging! If you have a high-energy adult dog, you’ll need to keep in mind that the right amount of exercise and positive dog training appropriate for your dog breed is essential. The most critical function of a shock collar is never to harm your furry best friend! The shock collar should be selected based on several features like range, beep option, level of correction, and rechargeable option.
The collar has a remote with a button that the pet parent can press. When pressed, the dog will receive a mild electronic stimulation from his electronic collar.
The frequency must be set on the lowest frequency possible so as not to harm the dog. The stimulation, in turn, makes the dog focus and allows for you to communicate with your dog clearly and consistently at all times. Here’s what it does:
- Teaches your dog to respond to the basic commands like Sit, Come, and Stay.
- It can be used to prevent dangerous behavior and to prevent pulling, chewing, and digging.
- Dogs can be trained from a distance away from you-300 plus-yards.
- Two dogs can be trained simultaneously.
- These collars are not recommended to stop barking.
This form of training is known as aversive avoidance training. Vibrating dog training collars should be used with the vibrating option only. The vibrating dog training collar is also known as a radius shock training collar or a remote dog training collar.
Vibrating dog collars should be used correctly and beneficial if used correctly and humanely to further any dog training. This form of exercise can deliver fast results. Most dogs respond instantly to the vibrating dog training collar for remote training and positive reinforcement combined with this training. Just ensure that you’re using the lowest levels of stimulation.
All remote training collars can be useful if used correctly. Small dog training can help curb and prevent unwanted behaviors and responses; nonetheless, learning how to use this training tool humanely by working with your positive trainer will yield more beneficial results for both you and your furry best friend.
Features of the Remote Dog Training Collar
- Three or more modes for dog training dogs-vibration tone and shock.
- An adjustable dog collar that fits all dog sizes from 10 lbs. to 120 lbs. They must be used correctly for each dog size.
- There is an automatic power save on the receiver.
- Different levels of vibration
- Different levels of shock
- Lightweight non-obtrusive collar
- Ideal way if used correctly and kindly for training dogs
- 900-1100 plus feet range of remote training
Are Radius Shock Collars Safe?
Training with a shock collar requires that you do everything so as not to inflict pain on your dog. All shock collars have a primary shock mechanism with varying intensities. By working together with a positive dog trainer from the get-go, you’ll have the best dog training methods at hand and your dog’s best interest, all the while using the radius shock collar. Always avoid using high-level frequencies that cause pain.
Price, Design, Use & Range
When we reviewed shock collars, we looked at ease-of-use and how complicated each instruction manual was. We also considered price point, together with the extended range and durability of the product, and looked at the most sought-after feature options like vibration options and tone setting.
We also checked if collars could be added to more than one dog. Vibrations and beep settings play an essential part in that they should be used independently of one another. When purchasing a shock collar, you’ll need to check to see if the design matches the intended use, so if you need a shock collar for long-distance field training or long hikes in the wilderness, you’ll need to purchase a waterproof, rugged, and durable shock collar with a higher than usual range. That said, if you’re training your dog around the home, then shorter range shock collars will work for you.
Choosing the right shock collar for your dog is essential. Automatic shock collars may be prone to malfunctioning because they tend to over-correct your dog. The range is a critical feature in working dogs and dogs that spend plenty of time outdoors.
How to First Use a Dog Shock Collar?
When introducing the radius shock collar to your dog, you’ll need to turn it on and see how it operates before putting it on your dog. By exploring the various shock collar functions, like sending a click or using the vibration setting, and understanding how to set it on the lowest level, you won’t accidentally hurt your pooch!
The collar must fit properly, and the placement of the collar is just as important. A collar should never be worn for too long and should never be too tight around your dog’s neck. The most important thing you can do when using a shock collar is to read and follow the instructions carefully. Here are some tips:
- Avoid leaving the radius shock collar on your dog for longer than specified within the manual.
- Move the collar around to reposition on your dog’s neck every so often.
- Always check the collar to make sure that there is no excessive pressure. Follow the instructions in the manual. These steps will keep your dog safe and comfortable.
- As always, check for signs of abrasions or a rash. Some dogs with sensitive skin may develop a rash or sores. If this does occur, discontinue until all scrapes have disappeared.
Ease of Use
Shock collars need to be easy-to-use and straightforward so that you don’t accidentally hurt your furry best friend. Settings need to be easy-to-read and marked to reduce the risk of confusing or harming your dog.
Conclusion for Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs
Using an e-Collar is a big decision and should always be done with plenty of thought. There are plenty of discussions worldwide about whether these e-Collars are an excellent training option and whether they are humane.
Before using an e-Collar on your pup, read up on all the precautions and work with your trainer so that you use the e-collar properly on your dog. You have to know how to combine dog sports, regular off-leash exercise, and positive dog training, and not use a shock collar as a “quick training fix.”
Additionally, your dog should have basic obedience classes first so that he can understand simple commands like “sit,” “stay,” “down,” and “come.” However, if you’re out hiking with your dog and have an emergency, there may be some perks to these as an aid.
Keep in mind that your dog needs to have as many rights similar to your child. We owe it to our dogs to train them in the most humane way possible and make their lives enjoyable and fun. Don’t try to make your dog live his life isolated in a backyard, lonely, bored with virtually no socialization or positive mental and physical stimulation.
Fill your dog’s lives with outdoor hiking trips, fun dog training classes with other dogs, trips to the dog beach, and don’t forget to organize those fun playdates with his best buddies at the dog park or home!
Other articles you would like:
Garrett loves animals and is a huge advocate for all Doodle dog breeds. He owns his own Goldendoodle named Kona. In addition, he volunteers at the Humane Society of Silicon Valley, where he fosters dogs and helps animals. Garrett enjoys writing about Doodles and believes that dogs can teach humans more about how to live than humans can teach a dog.
Why Trust We Love Doodles?
At We Love Doodles, we’re a team of writers, veterinarians, and puppy trainers that love dogs. Our team of qualified experts researches and provides reliable information on a wide range of dog topics. Our reviews are based on customer feedback, hands-on testing, and in-depth analysis. We are fully transparent and honest to our community of dog owners and future owners.