Are you considering getting a DNA test for your new pet and can’t decide between Wisdom Panel vs Embark? Then you’ve come to the right place.
There are a few companies that provide DNA examination facilities for dogs, but Wisdom Panel and Embark are the leading firms. They execute thorough analyses on all dog breeds to determine the genetic composition of your pet.
If you’re curious which examination is suitable for your pooch, don’t worry. We’re here to delve into the issue of Wisdom Panel vs Embark and consider the advantages and disadvantages of each service.
Before you scroll down to an in-depth comparison, check out: PupBox vs. BarkBox: Subscription Box Guide! (2023) and Pawrade vs. PuppySpot: Review and Comparison! (2023).
Which Dog Breed DNA Test Is Most Accurate?
Both of these DNA tests are highly accurate, according to these companies.
Wisdom Panel claims that the Wisdom Panel Premium Kit has a 98% accuracy rating as of 2022. This is a significant jump from their precious claim of 93% accuracy back in 2019.
On the other hand, Embark claims that their breed results are between 95% to 99% accurate as of 2022. These numbers are close to Wisdom Panel’s records.
While Embark may not test for quite as many dog breeds, they test more dogs than their competition, and more samples lead to higher accuracy.
While it is hard to give an explicit winner in this category, we would say that Wisdom Panel edges out Embark. Wisdom Panel gives a bit more consistency in their testing and ends up with more accurate results on average.
Is Wisdom Panel More Accurate Than Embark?
While the accuracy of results will vary from dog to dog, Wisdom Panel typically gives more accurate testing than Embark.
As stated before, Wisdom Panel offers a consistent 98% accuracy rate, while Embark falls between 95% to 99%. So, Embark may have the capability to provide more accurate DNA results. Still, their average sample will be just the slightest bit less accurate.
How Expensive Is Each Service?
Wisdom Panel offers better value for the amount that you are paying. Wisdom Panel offers a generic breed ID test for $79.99 and a premium test for $99.99.
Even considering the premium price, Wisdom Panel edges out Embark’s $129 package by almost $30. Dog owners on a tight budget should definitely look into Wisdom Panel for their cheaper testing services.
Which DNA Test Is Easier To Use?
While Embark and Wisdom Panel use cotton swab saliva tests, some differences set them apart.
Embark starts by suggesting owners leave a treat in front of their dog. The treat will get the dog salivating and hopefully helps them to sit still. Then you take the long cotton swab and hold it inside the dog’s mouth for 30 seconds.
The test kit comes with multiple inserts you can use. If you have trouble getting your dog to sit still, it is suggested that you get a second person to help hold them still. After obtaining the sample, the Embark instructions will tell you to hold it in a container and shake it for a few seconds.
Wisdom Panel‘s DNA kit follows most of the same steps as Embark, but their instructions are slightly more streamlined. Wisdom Panel offers a longer cotton swab akin to a mascara wand, which makes collecting the sample less messy. On top of that, Wisdom Panel’s test doesn’t overwhelm you with a bunch of extra parts like a Lego kit. The test comes with just the needed materials, with no additional fuss.
Overall, we would give the edge to Wisdom Panel in this category. While the difference is mild, the directions for Wisdom Panel are more intuitive.
Which Test Provides Faster Results?
Embark is transparent in disclosing that its DNA examination procedure requires more time than other tests. Since the firm receives a larger quantity of DNA samples than its rivals, it’s only logical that the processing time is not as swift.
Embark’s turnaround time for results is one to two months after you’ve sent your DNA sample for testing. Although a wait of one to two months is manageable, Wisdom Panel is unquestionably a quicker service.
Wisdom Panel delivers findings in only two to three weeks, which may be four times faster than Embark’s processing time.
How Accurate Is Embark Health Test?
Embark DNA testing has improved a lot over the last few years.
In 2009, the National Canine Research Council found that the test only gave accurate results 84% of the time. However, the company has since claimed that their test is between 95% to 99% accurate.
Embark has an in-house quality control team set to catch when a test might have a mistake. Suppose probe testing results do not match two of a gene. In that case, the company will take on a second analysis by new geneticists to determine the actual nucleotide.
On top of testing for breeds, the Embark DNA test checks for relatives in the sample to ensure the results are as accurate as possible. The company does this to make testing for errors and repeat dogs easier.
Even assuming the lowest accuracy, 95% correct, it is still excellent and can reasonably be used.
How Accurate Is Wisdom Panel Dog DNA?
The Wisdom Panel health test is highly accurate. This DNA test looks at over 200,00 genetic markers inside your dog to test for any breeds found within the last three generations. Even if your dog’s genome only shows a small percentage of a breed, the test will likely pick up on it.
In the end, Wisdom Panel is highly accurate and has shown a 98% success rate as of 2022.
Can DNA Test Results Be Wrong?
Whether it is testing for your dog or 23andMe, any kind of DNA test can give inaccurate results. Even the most accurate testing facilities in the world can’t claim a higher rate than 99.9%.
There are a few key reasons companies can’t create a perfectly accurate DNA test.
First of all, DNA testing is done by humans. Humans must move the DNA, handle it, and perform the tests. This leaves room for human errors, so even if a testing practice works perfectly every time, that assumes that humans can perform the test perfectly every time.
Between mishandling a sample, contamination, or even tripping, there is no guarantee that the employees will not make a mistake when examining DNA.
The second reason for error comes from interpretation. Workers and databases will interpret a DNA sample and assign it a breed. While this works well on paper, some breeds are similar enough that getting their results mixed up is not unreasonable.
There is also the issue of grouping. Some DNA samples will get grouped in with the wrong breed because that is the closest thing available. If your DNA kit only tests for 100 breeds and your dog has genes from a breed outside of those 100, the test might round your dog over to the closest breed.
The last big area where error can occur is with the initial DNA sample. Some DNA samples are taken incorrectly, so they may not provide the adequate amount of specimen that the test requires.
Swabbing can go wrong, but there can be an issue if your dog has had a major operation that has changed its genome. Things such as bone marrow transplants or a blood transfusion can put new genomes into a dog’s body, and it will be reflected in a DNA sample.
Overall, DNA testing is typically accurate. But it is important to understand that it could be better and that things can go wrong to change the accuracy of results, even if some of these situations are niche.
Frequently Asked Questions
While we have covered a lot of information on Wisdom Panel vs Embark, there might still be some unanswered questions. The following are some of the most common.
Yes, Embark will tell you if your dog is purebred.
To uncover your canine’s hereditary composition, the Embark DNA test can detect and verify its lineage genes.
Yes, Embark will detect if your dog has coyote ancestry. The Embark DNA test will detect over 200 different dog breeds. This kit even includes wolf and coyote genetic testing for your dog.
Unfortunately, the Embark DNA test kit won’t give you your dog’s age. But the good news is that Embark offers a separate test specifically for determining your dog’s age.
The age test works by examining methylation in your dog’s DNA. The test is conducted in a similar way to DNA testing, but it comes with a price tag of $159, which is pricier than other test kits.
Breeders use the Embark DNA test to test their dog’s lineage utilizing quick, simple, and accurate means. The test is inexpensive and quick, allowing breeders to quickly identify features in their dogs and continue to breed the qualities they desire.
Wisdom Panel test kits check for over 350 different breeds in your dog. This makes this test kit a premier choice for those who suspect an uncommon breed in their dog’s ancestry.
Wisdom Panel is the DNA testing kit with the most accurate results and is, therefore, the most trusted by veterinarians. The test receives good reviews on every platform it offers due to its research-grade data and enormous database of information.
While this question is subjective, many medical professionals agree that dog DNA tests are worth the money.
A dog DNA test will help give the pet owner and their vet a better idea of your dog’s ancestry. This means that you will have an easier time preventing and treating common ailments that correspond with certain breeds.
DNA tests are especially worth it for dog breeders, as it is essential if they want to receive specific results and continue breeding.
Wisdom Panel is one of the fastest dog DNA test kits.
The test itself only takes about a minute while you gather the sample. Then after sending in a sample, Wisdom Panel kits take two to four weeks to receive results, usually toward the faster end of that spectrum.
Yes, veterinarians can perform a DNA test for your dog. Some vets will use a blood sample from your dog to test their DNA, while others will use the same boxed kits you can buy yourself.
Yes, Embark can identify your dog’s siblings. If you send in your dog’s DNA using an Embark test kit, the company can look for dogs in their database to see if any of the DNA comes up as a sibling. Assuming your dog’s sibling has also taken a DNA test with the company, they can match them together.
If you suspect who might be a sibling of your dog, you can also send in a DNA sample of both dogs to check if they are siblings directly.
Conclusion for “Wisdom Panel vs Embark Review”
When it comes to comparing Wisdom Panel vs Embark, there are benefits to each test.
Embark is an accurate test with an extensive database of information that vets trust.
On the other hand, Wisdom Panel may be slightly more accurate. It is also much quicker than Embark, offering more instant gratification than the former.
Which test is better depends on what is important to you when testing your dog’s DNA.
If you find this guide, “Wisdom Panel vs Embark Review,” helpful, check out:
- FI vs Whistle Dog Collar Review! (2023)
- PetPlate vs Ollie: Dog Food Delivery Comparison! (2023)
- Healthy Paws vs Pumpkin – Dog Health Insurance Comparison! (2023)
Learn more by watching “Embark vs. Wisdom Panel – Dog DNA Test” down below:
Garrett loves animals and is a huge advocate for all Doodle dog breeds. He owns his own Goldendoodle named Kona. In addition, he volunteers at the Humane Society of Silicon Valley, where he fosters dogs and helps animals. Garrett enjoys writing about Doodles and believes that dogs can teach humans more about how to live than humans can teach a dog.
Why Trust We Love Doodles?
At We Love Doodles, we’re a team of writers, veterinarians, and puppy trainers that love dogs. Our team of qualified experts researches and provides reliable information on a wide range of dog topics. Our reviews are based on customer feedback, hands-on testing, and in-depth analysis. We are fully transparent and honest to our community of dog owners and future owners.